Dove Cameron is an actress that has never been lacking in talent. From her years starring in Disney Channel productions such as “Liv and Maddie” and the “Descendants” franchise to her later ventures into music, she has consistently demonstrated an immensely impressive vocal ability that, for many listeners, strongly suggested the potential for something considerably ambitious.

However, with the Nov. 6 release of her long-awaited debut studio album, “FINAL GIRL,” Cameron seems to have taken a musical direction that does not fully do justice to her capabilities. Although the record features several compelling lyrical moments and demonstrates her willingness to explore deeply introspective subject matter, its inconsistent production and seemingly uncertain artistic identity leave much to be desired. Rather than embracing her impressive vocal range, control, and technical ability that have all distinguished her throughout her career as both an actress and singer, Cameron appears to have started to lean heavily into glossy synth-pop, disco-inspired production, and the trend-conscious sounds of contemporary Gen Z pop, resulting in an album that does not feel like a successfully definitive introduction of her artistry to the musical world.

For Cameron, the transition from Disney star to musical artist has been a gradual one, with her earlier releases offering glimpses of a darker, more distinctive sound. Her 2023 debut EP “Alchemical: Volume 1,” particularly its breakthrough single “Boyfriend,” introduced listeners to a gothic, alternative pop aesthetic that felt both beautifully and satisfyingly unconventional. Songs like “Boyfriend” and “Sand” were able to demonstrate Cameron’s ability to create a sound that felt more individual than much of the pop music of our current era. This earlier direction seemed to offer Cameron an opportunity to establish a recognizable artistic identity, much like the path that allowed former Disney stars such as Sabrina Carpenter and Olivia Rodrigo to make names for themselves. Consequently, expectations surrounding “FINAL GIRL” were understandably high, particularly for listeners who had been anticipating a full-length project that would further develop the sound that Cameron had begun to establish in the past decade.

However, to many fans’ disappointment, much of “FINAL GIRL” seems to move in a different direction, one that seems uncertain of itself. While the album does incorporate varying elements of alternative pop and theatrical balladry like “Alchemical: Volume 1” did, these influences do not always feel as though they belong to the same artistic vision. “when in rome,” for instance, leans into a bright, upbeat, synth sound that is driven by nostalgic pop vibes; while “emerald” incorporates a jazzier instrumentation and style. “do the math,” on the other hand, embraces a sharper, more theatrical glam-pop sound, and “hot girl” opts for a much more energetic, brash-pop production. Although each track has its own appeal, many feel that the transitions between these different styles can make the album feel somewhat scattered and inconsistent, particularly when the more polished, dance-oriented tracks are placed alongside its darker and more introspective moments. Of course, there is nothing inherently wrong with an album experimenting with a variety of genres; Olivia Rodrigo, for instance, has demonstrated in all of her albums that slower, emotionally driven ballads can coexist with more aggressive pop-rock and punk-influenced tracks without sacrificing the overall identity of an album. The distinction between the two former Disney stars, therefore, lies in cohesion and deliberateness. Across “FINAL GIRL,” Cameron’s stylistic shifts often feel like an inability to settle on a clear musical direction, whereas Rodrigo’s varied sound comes across as a more deliberate form of experimentation, both musically and emotionally. Rather than developing a sound that is distinctly her own, Cameron’s album occasionally comes across as an assortment of contemporary pop influences without a particularly strong foundation to hold them together.

This uncertainty is also reflected in the album’s production, which at times feels overly concerned with fitting into the current pop landscape. There is a certain theatricality to Cameron’s new musical direction, but much of it seems to draw upon sounds and aesthetics that have already become familiar within the genre of pop, especially online. These include the glossy dance-pop and synth-heavy production heard on albums such as Addison Rae’s “Addison” (June 2025), Zara Larsson’s “Midnight Sun” (September 2025), and Tate McRae’s “So Close to What” (February 2025). Some listeners have described the album as feeling particularly “TikToky,” suggesting that, despite the variation in its musicality, many of its production choices still seem rooted in the kind of immediately recognizable, trend-conscious pop that performs well on social media. One TikTok commenter went so far as to describe the rebrand as “So unauthentic and I feel like that’s the disconnect … she is trying to create an image rather than trial and error naturally.” Another expressed a similar sentiment: “It all feels so soulless and corporate … it doesn’t fit her.” While this is not necessarily an indication of Cameron’s intentions, it does raise an interesting question about whether her new artistic identity is being shaped more by modern expectations than by her own musical strengths. Her rebrand feels as though it is attempting to establish her as a particular kind of Gen Z pop artist, but in doing so, it occasionally seems to overlook the qualities that made her stand out in the first place as a Disney star.

Furthermore, it is interesting to note that much of the criticism surrounding Cameron’s new direction has centered not on her voice or talent, but on the way in which they are both being utilized. Following live performances of “final girl,” what would be considered the title track but does not appear on the official eleven-track listing, some listeners took to TikTok to question why Cameron had chosen this particular direction and image for her musical debut. One commenter remarked, “She has such a beautiful voice I wonder why she chose this genre of music,” while another agreed, suggesting, “She needs to find her niche … [this] is not fitting her and she’s very talented.” Although these comments solely represent individual reactions rather than a definitive consensus among listeners, they reflect a seemingly recurring frustration with Cameron’s current direction: the idea that her vocal abilities are not being given the opportunity to reach their full potential. Rather than questioning whether she can sing, listeners seem more interested in wondering what she might sound like if she gave herself the material to truly demonstrate what she can do, as she has clearly done during her time on Disney.

That being said, it would be unfair to suggest that “FINAL GIRL” is entirely without merit. Cameron’s songwriting is praised for its thoughtfulness and sentimentality, particularly when she addresses experiences surrounding childhood, trauma, relationships, and grief. The opening track, “silver screen baby,” offers an intimate reflection on her upbringing and early aspirations as a young actress, while “hands of man” confronts sexual violence and the ways in which society continues to excuse harmful behavior toward women. The closing track, “maybe heaven is a jazz club,” is particularly heartfelt, serving as a tribute to Cameron’s late father and her close friend Cameron Boyce. These songs demonstrate that Cameron has meaningful experiences to draw upon and is clearly more than capable of translating them into strong lyrical material. Unfortunately, the strength of these concepts is not always matched by the musical arrangements surrounding them, leaving several tracks feeling as though they could have benefited from a more deliberate and distinctive sonic approach.

Ultimately, what makes the sound of “FINAL GIRL” fall short of many listeners’ expectations is the feeling that Cameron is capable of delivering something much greater than what the album offers. Her vocal ability is undeniable, her songwriting demonstrates significant promise, and her earlier work suggests that she is more than capable of establishing a unique artistic identity. Yet, rather than fully developing the darker, more alternative sound that first attracted many listeners to her music, Cameron seems to have moved in a more conventional, contemporary pop direction that fans do not believe will distinguish her from other artists of our generation. For an artist with such an impressive voice and artistic career, the greatest disappointment of Cameron’s “FINAL GIRL” is that it leaves so much of her potential unexplored.



Owusu Delivers Late as Yellowjackets Hold Off Allegheny in Season Opener

The Palestra erupted when Owusu came away with a steal and threw down a dunk to extend URochester’s lead to 15-3. On the defensive end, 7 foot tall fourth-year Forward David Ackles (34) denied Allegheny’s third-year Guard Eli Teslovich (13) a layup, drawing another roar from the crowd. Read More

DPS responds to student concerns over newly-placed security cameras and other security developments

The Student Association Government (SA) invited representatives from the URochester's Department of Public Safety (DPS) to the latest senate meeting Monday, Nov. 9, to answer questions and discuss the University’s increased campus surveillance as well as other safety concerns.  Read More

First Section of Tunnels Open Just in Time for Winter Months

The River Campus tunnels will reopen in two waves this November following a closure that began in the summer. Read More