DiFranco’s career is in its teen years right now. Ever since her 1990s debut Ani has gathered a myriad of loyal followers and redefined the definition of coffee shop folk into a culture by itself. She offered great escapism from the Lilith Fair crowd and penned lyrics so witty and timely they are etched on the tombstone of the riot-grrl era. However, ever since “To The Teeth” her music has been waning in lyrical pizzaz and edgy folkness.

DiFranco has meandered into big-band jazziness and forgot about the feisty rock she does best. Her previous double album left the early DiFranco fan hungry for a better treat and considering Ani’s impressive back catalogue, a mediocre album is forgiven. DiFranco, however, returns with the long-awaited “Evolve,” but the wait is not worth it.

The album is packed with midtempo and smokey-bar tunes that meshed into one another for the lack of distinction. The exciting shrewd melodies of DiFranco are long gone and now it is merely a mixture of brown, kind of like when different colors seep into each other in a watercolor painting.

“Promised Land” is a bland and directionless ode, while “Icarus” is basically disappointing.

“In The Way” starts out promising and “Slide” is reminiscent of a less-inspired “Jukebox.”

The title track has some Ani kitsch to it, while “Shrug” is a lazy song with extra distorted vocals.

“Here For Now” is the only complete song, with credible instrumentation, but toward the end it gets redundant. “Serpentine” is a 10-minute-plus trip continuing the Ani tradition of long numbers toward the end of recent albums, yet this song is more of a politically and socially aware record of current events.

The album closes with “Welcome To” and leaves us wondering what happened to the girl with the guitar. Did she find a band and discover saxophones and get her voice drowned by all that?

Coming from an avid DiFranco fan, I find this album second-rate and lower than my expectations. If you loved “Imperfectly” and “Not So Soft,” don’t expect the same feel. If you thought “Reckoning / Revelling” was mediocre, then this is definitely not an album to purchase. I never thought I’d give Ani DiFranco a bad review, but “Evolve” is an evolution toward the bargain bins.

Al-Qatami can be reached at nalqatami@campustimes.org.



Live updates: Wallis Hall sit-ins

Editor’s Note (5/4/24): This article is no longer being updated. For our most up to date coverage, look for articles…

Riseup with Riseman

“I decided to make one for fun — really poor quality — and I put it on my Instagram just to see how people would react," Riseman said.

UR Baseball beats Hamilton and RIT

Yellowjackets baseball beat Hamilton College on Tuesday and RIT on Friday to the scores of 11–4 and 7–4, respectively.