Gilbert Kirton exemplified professionalism in the classroom

Last week’s article, entitled ‘Student Charged for Child Porn,” strongly implied that CAS 105 instructor and English graduate student Gilbert Kirton infused his lessons with aspects of his personal life. As a former student of Kirton’s, I know this to be false.

Within the classroom, there was never any semblance of Kirton’s personal life choices. Kirton created two CAS 105 courses on the topic of exposing hidden sexual references in American culture, which he knew would interest a crowd of undergraduate students. His courses were popular and filled quickly.

The names of the courses, ‘Provocative Solicitations: The Art of Seduction in Advertising” and ‘Fairies, Hos, and Mistletoe,” along with their official course descriptions, both candidly depicted the sometimes unorthodox content of the courses. Most of the students who thought they might be offended by the content of the courses simply did not take them; therefore, the students who found themselves uncomfortable amidst in-class discussion were always few to no one.

Unfortunately, however, last week’s article reported on the opinions of this miniscule minority as if they were in fact the opinions of the majority, a detail that could result in a dangerous public misconception.

The article spoke of Kirton’s in-class ‘sexually charged interpretations” as if it was supposed to be shocking that the professor of a writing course on analyzing subliminal sexuality in American culture would dare disclose aspects of subliminal sexuality in American culture.

For as long as I sat in his classroom, Kirton never once stepped outside the contents of the official course description. Despite the regrettable realities of his personal life, as our teacher, Gilbert Kirton was always professional and respectful toward his students, as well as knowledgeable and enthusiastic. For these reasons, he was well-liked by the vast majority of his students.

Julia Winer
Class of 2010



Letter to the Editor

When McGeary begins his tenure in March in the role of Andrew H. and Janet Dayton Neilly Dean of URochester Libraries, he will bring with him his experience of a career shaped by the changing role of libraries in a digital world. At Duke University, where he currently works, McGeary has helped oversee the systems and services that support teaching, research, and scholarship, for example, by digitally preserving data and developing new software. Read More

Letter to the Editor

Traffic mitigation, the main goal of the congestion relief program, has been an inarguable and impressive success. The major bridge and tunnel crossings into the tolled area of Manhattan saw an astounding 23% average decrease in rush hour travel time, ranging from 6.7% on the Manhattan Bridge all the way to 51% in the Holland Tunnel. Read More

Letter to the Editor

A new dining option for Southwestern cuisine has come to campus, as announced in a URochester dining Instagram post at the beginning of the semester.  “Fresh. Fast. Flavorful. These aren’t just words; they are the standard our team is ready to set,” the Instagram post read.  The establishment, named Blue Cactus, sells Southwestern quesadillas, burritos, […]