College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

VOX protests and petitions

By Sumya Hasan

|

Published: Thursday, November 6, 2008

Updated: Thursday, November 6, 2008

On Oct. 31, members of the Women’s Caucus, its sub-committee VOX and representatives from local Rochester organizations joined forces to inform UR students that Crisis Pregnancy Centers, or CPCs, have been misleading women with inaccurate medical information on abortions.

The rally capped off the Women’s Caucus and VOX sponsored CPC Week of Action. Group members tabled throughout the week to inform the student body about CPCs.
There was also a petition circulating to stop federal funding of such centers, 11 of which are located in the Rochester area. There were several hundred signatures on the petition.
At this time, Women’s Caucus is continuing to raise awareness by hanging up more flyers educating women about additional pregnancy centers to contact.

Approximately three weeks ago, flyers were hung in Wilson Commons that offered information to women who were pregnant.

These flyers mentioned the names of three CPCs that claimed they would help women weigh all of the options available to them when expecting a child.

According to sophomore Adelaide Kuehn, a liaison between VOX and Women’s Caucus, the centers exaggerated the risks of abortions. The flyers mentioned that having an abortion in general would severely increase psychological trauma experienced by the mother and increase her risk of breast cancer. The CPCs also stressed that abortions can possibly cause pelvic inflammatory disease, which prevents chances of a future pregnancy.

They did not specify that the risks increase by the trimester, but instead spent much of their time providing information to persuade  the women from getting an abortion.

Birthright and Compass Care, two of the CPCs that were included in the flyers pinned in Wilson Commons a few weeks ago, evidently were not aware of the fact that Women’s Caucus held a rally to prevent further federal funding of their centers.

Birthright stated that they do not get involved in politics and that they have never directly campaigned in any university setting.

Director of Birthright Joan Rohr says that the center is a support system for women under sensitive and frightening circumstances.

“People are rushed into making decisions, which is why they don’t have the time to consider all of their options,” she said.

They have a staff comprised of volunteers who are there to listen rather than talk so that they can understand where the woman is coming from and figure out why they may believe that an abortion is the only answer.

Compass Care, another CPC in the Rochester area, offers a 15-step service for women who are looking to learn about their options. According to an exit survey conducted by the CPC, women spoke favorably about the center’s professional services and caring environment.

President of Compass Care Jim Harden said that the nonprofit organization strives to be unbiased.

“We have a very nonjudgmental environment and work through this difficult time with her,” Harden said. “Research shows that women want to go to nonprofit organizations so that the organization doesn’t benefit from their choices either way.”

Women’s Caucus Vice President and senior Julianne Nigro emphasized that the group does not intend to interfere with CPCs. Though the CPC Week of Action was in response to the misleading flyers, the main goal of the week was to educate UR students.

“We want to make it clear that we do not object to the CPCs or their advertising,” she said. “We find fault in the fact that they give out medically inaccurate information and they disguise themselves as pro-choice and attempt to scare women from making their own decisions regarding abortion.”

Nigro and Kuehn, along with Women’s Caucus and VOX, are working for awareness of this issue at hand. Women’s Caucus is continuing its work for the right of women to be informed and receive all of the information needed.

This past Monday, the community organizer from NARAL Pro-Choice N.Y. Lalena Howard joined the weekly Women’s Caucus meeting in the Ruth Merrill Center to discuss ways for students to continue to stay involved in supporting women’s health and women’s choice.

Howard specifically addressed various pieces of legislation and distributed a number of pertinent petitions to those present at the meeting. 

Hasan is a member of the class of 2012.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

3 comments Log in to Comment

Julie
Fri Nov 7 2008 14:37
NARAL and Planned Parenthood are extremely biased by the fact that they make millions of dollars by selling sex and doing abortions that result from sexual activity. Their advertising is most deceptive (they are certainly not helping women plan to be parents). They convince over 90% of the pregnant women they see to abort - for their own profit. They receive millions in federal and state tax dollars while CPCs get nothing from state or federal taxes. Someone writing this article needs to get their facts straight.

Julie N.

Julie
Thu Nov 6 2008 15:33
NARAL and Planned Parenthood are extremely biased by the fact that they make millions of dollars by selling sex and doing abortions that result from sexual activity. Their advertising is most deceptive (they are certainly not helping women plan to be parents). They convince over 90% of the pregnant women they see to abort - for their own profit. They receive millions in federal and state tax dollars while CPCs get nothing from state or federal taxes. Someone writing this article needs to get their facts straight.

Julie N.

Jim Harden
Thu Nov 6 2008 12:26
I am Jim Harden, President of CompassCare quoted in the article above. To be clear, CompassCare actually is a medical office and not a CPC as described. Services offered include limited OB care including pregnancy confirmation and well as selected Sexually Transmitted Disease testing and total options consultation (which I mentioned in the interview). We have never recieved any federal monies and likely never will. Unlike direct abortion providers we do not benefit financially from any decision a woman makes and strive to support her whichever route she chooses. The Women's Caucus should be careful not to apply the boilerplate rhetoric recieved by NARAL in a misleading fashion. Furthermore, there is being assumed in this article that there is a set standard of accurate information. Who set that standard, where is it, and is it being followed at abotion clinics like Planned Parenthood? All of our medical services and data is professional, comprehensive, and standardized to accepted medical standards of care with direct physician oversight. If NARAL, VOX and the Women's Caucus are truly interested in empowering women with comprehensive and accurate information perhaps we should sit down at the same table and come to an agreement regarding proper standards of care. But it may be that real women's health and empowerment is not their true aim but rather a political agenda.

You must be logged in to comment on an article. Not already a member? Register now

Log In